An osteoporosis diagnosis can change how you think about your body.
Things you previously did without a second thought might suddenly feel questionable. Carrying a heavy bag of compost, lifting a suitcase into the car, stepping down from a wall or taking a slightly slippery path.
You might start wondering whether these are things you should still be doing at all..
And if you look online for advice about exercising with osteoporosis, you'll find plenty of information about what to do, what not to do and what might put you at risk.
Some caution is entirely appropriate. Osteoporosis affects bone strength and increases fracture risk, and that needs to be taken seriously.
But there's another side to this conversation that I think deserves more attention. What happens when being careful gradually turns into doing less?
When a diagnosis changes how you move
One of the things we've noticed through our work at WildStrong is how much people's beliefs about their bodies influence what they feel comfortable doing.
A diagnosis, an injury or even a well-meaning comment from a healthcare professional can change someone's confidence in their ability to move.
Perhaps you stop getting down onto the floor because you're worried about getting back up. You start asking someone else to carry the heavier shopping. You avoid uneven ground because you're no longer quite sure you trust your balance.
Each decision might seem sensible in isolation. But over time, avoiding activities can mean fewer opportunities to practise the very skills and strengths that help us stay capable.
And everyday life doesn't stop making physical demands.
There are still stairs to climb, bags to carry, gardens to look after and things to pick up from the floor.
So while understanding fracture risk is important, we also need to think about how people can continue developing the strength, balance and confidence to do the things that matter to them.
That's where appropriate exercise becomes particularly valuable.
What kinds of exercise help with osteoporosis?
When people search for weight-bearing exercises for osteoporosis, they're often looking for a list of recommended activities.
Walking, dancing, climbing stairs and jogging are all examples of weight-bearing movement. They involve supporting your bodyweight through your legs, rather than having it supported by water or a bicycle.
But not all weight-bearing activities challenge our bones in the same way.
Walking is a excellent activity for many reasons, including cardiovascular health, getting outdoors and maintaining general mobility. However, walking alone is unlikely to provide enough stimulus to substantially improve bone density for many people.
To understand why, it helps to know a little about how bones respond to exercise.
Our bones are living tissues. They continually remodel themselves in response to a range of influences, including the mechanical demands we place on them.
For exercise to stimulate adaptation, those demands need to be sufficiently challenging.
Two particularly important approaches are progressive resistance training and appropriate impact exercise.
Strength training
Strength training involves working against resistance. That might mean lifting dumbbells, using resistance bands or working with objects you have around the house.
As your muscles produce force, they also place forces on your bones.
The challenge needs to be appropriate for you, and it generally needs to increase over time as you become stronger.
A 6kg dumbbell might be challenging for one person but relatively easy for another. Even for the same person, that weight might be demanding for a shoulder exercise and far too light for a squat.
That's why we can't simply prescribe one weight and assume it's suitable for everybody.
Impact exercise
Impact exercise involves activities where the body experiences forces from contact with the ground.
Depending on someone's capabilities and fracture risk, this might involve anything from purposeful stepping and controlled heel drops to hopping or jumping.
The aim isn't to create the biggest impact possible. It's to find an appropriate level of challenge and build from there.
Impact training also needs to be considered alongside strength, balance and an individual's fracture history.
For some people, higher-impact activities may not be appropriate, at least initially. There are still plenty of useful ways to train.
Can you lift heavy weights with osteoporosis?
This is an area where our understanding has developed considerably.
For a long time, people with low bone density were often encouraged to stick to very light exercise.
But research has challenged the assumption that heavier resistance training is automatically inappropriate.
One particularly interesting example is the Australian LIFTMOR trial, which investigated high-intensity resistance and impact training in postmenopausal women with osteopenia or osteoporosis.
Participants completed two supervised, 30-minute sessions per week over eight months, using heavy resistance exercises (typically five sets of five repetitions at more than 85% of their one-repetition maximum) alongside impact training.
Compared with a low-intensity, home-based exercise group, participants showed improvements in lumbar spine bone mineral density, better preservation of bone density at the femoral neck, and improvements in measures of physical function.
Importantly, participants were screened before taking part, exercises were taught and progressively loaded, and sessions were closely supervised. The findings are encouraging, although they do not mean that the same training approach will be appropriate for everyone with low bone density.
It doesn't mean everyone with osteoporosis should immediately start lifting heavy weights. What it does suggest is that, for appropriately assessed individuals, resistance training can be considerably more challenging than people might previously have assumed.
The important question is how to find the right level of challenge for the person in front of us.
Finding a starting point that works for you
At WildStrong, we spend a lot of time helping people explore different ways to perform a movement.
Take a squat or a sit-to-stand, for example.
One person might begin by standing up from a relatively high chair, perhaps using their hands for a little assistance.
Another might squat while holding a weight in front of them.
Someone with more experience might be ready for a considerably heavier load or a great range of motion in the squat (a deep controlled squat).
These are all ways of exploring a similar movement pattern, but the demands are different.
We can change the height of the chair, the range of motion, the amount of assistance or the resistance.
As someone develops strength and confidence, we can gradually adjust to those demands.
The same approach applies to picking things up, pushing, pulling, stepping and carrying.
Rather than asking everyone to perform exactly the same exercise, we're looking for a version that provides a useful challenge without exceeding their current capabilities.
This is particularly important when working with osteoporosis, where previous fractures, spinal health, balance, pain and exercise experience all need to be considered.
If you've experienced vertebral fractures, multiple fragility fractures or have other significant health concerns, it's worth getting individual advice from a physiotherapist or appropriately qualified healthcare professional before introducing more demanding exercise.
Are there exercises you should avoid with osteoporosis?
This is understandably one of the biggest questions people have.
The UK expert consensus on exercise and osteoporosis offers guidance on staying active while managing fracture risk.
One important consideration is repeated or heavily loaded bending through the spine, particularly into end-range flexion, which may increase risk for some people with osteoporosis.
For example, someone with vertebral fractures may need to adapt exercises involving significant spinal rounding, especially under load.
Learning to hinge through the hips can be a useful skill when picking things up, because it gives us another way to organise the movement and manage the forces involved.
But it would be a mistake to turn every movement into a universal list of things that are either safe or unsafe.
People have different fracture histories, capabilities and levels of experience.
Someone who has been strength training consistently for years may have very different needs from someone who is returning to exercise after a long period of inactivity.
Good exercise advice needs to take those differences into account.
And importantly, avoiding particular movements doesn't have to mean avoiding movement altogether.
Strength for everyday life
One of the things I find interesting is how differently we sometimes think about exercise and ordinary activities.
Someone might happily lift a bag of compost into their car but feel nervous when handed an 8kg kettlebell.
Yet both involve producing force, managing a load and coordinating movement.
Of course, that doesn't mean every everyday activity is automatically appropriate for someone with osteoporosis.
But it does remind us that strength training isn't separate from life.
We squat when we sit down and stand up. We hinge when we pick something up. We carry shopping, push heavy doors, climb steps and move objects around our homes.
Strength training gives us an opportunity to practise and progressively develop the physical capabilities involved in those activities.
And it's not only about strength.
Being able to react when we lose our balance, move confidently across uneven ground or get up from the floor can also make a real difference to how we navigate everyday life.
These are skills we can continue to practise and develop.
Do you need a gym to get started?
Not necessarily. A gym can be an excellent place to strength train, particularly because it's relatively easy to adjust resistance and progressively increase the challenge.
But there's plenty you can do at home too.
You might begin with standing up from a chair, stepping onto a low step, pushing against a kitchen worktop or carrying something around the house.
As those activities become easier, you can explore ways to make them more challenging.
You may eventually need additional resistance to keep progressing. Dumbbells, kettlebells and other equipment can be useful for that, but you don't need a fully equipped home gym to begin.
The key is having a manageable starting point and a way to progress.
If you're unsure where to begin, we've put together a free How to Start Strength Training guide, with practical ideas for getting started at home.
Your bone density is important but so is everything else.
Bone density and reducing fracture risk are important and exercise is only one part of osteoporosis management, alongside any medical treatment and other advice you've been given.
But I think it's also worth asking what we're trying to preserve or improve through all of this.
For many people, it's the ability to keep doing the things they enjoy.
Carrying their own bags when travelling, getting down onto the floor to play with grandchildren, gardening, walking somewhere new, feeling confident enough to try something unfamiliar.
An osteoporosis diagnosis gives us important information about our bones, but it doesn't tell us everything about what we're capable of.
Appropriate strength training offers an opportunity to build on what we can already do, gradually develop new capabilities and become more confident in how we move.
And perhaps that's a useful question to take away from an osteoporosis diagnosis.
Not simply, “What should I stop doing?”
But also, “What do I want to keep doing, and what strength and skills might help me do it?”
Once we understand what we're trying to achieve, we have far more options for how to get there. And you can find something that works for you, rather than trying to make you fit the exercise.
If you'd like to explore some practical starting points, our WildStrong movement tutorials demonstrate a range of strength and everyday movement activities.

